I read this book a couple months ago but couldn’t bring myself to blog about it. Why? Because the subject matter was so difficult for me. Here’s the summary: “After her former friend Leah dies in an automobile accident, Laine remembers their troubled relationship, dating back to elementary school when Leah convinced Laine to ‘practice’ in the closet with her, and Leah controlled her every thought.”
Even though I never had a Leah in my life, at least not that exact model, I’ve known and experienced Laine’s fear and confusion at the hands of supposed friends. It’s a horrible place to be. And Jo Knowles’s spare and deliberate storytelling took me right back there. There is no way I could have finished reading such a painful story if it hadn’t been written so well; I was practically looking for an excuse to put down the book.
From page 66: When we get back to the house, Leah acts especially cheerful, urging everyone to have a second piece of birthday cake. She makes sure Paige has a seat next to her. Later we climb into sleeping bags spread out on Leah’s bedroom floor. Leah puts Paige’s sleeping bag next to hers before I can spread mine there. This is it, I think. Paige is the new me. Maybe I should be relieved.
Typing out those words just now made my heart pound as I remembered the conflicting feelings I’ve had for friends/tormentors in my own life. Your head tells you one thing, your heart another, and pretty soon you don’t know up from down.
Knowles does a superb job of putting us in Laine’s head, sharing all those tipping moments when she could have (should have?) stepped away and escaped the hurt. But no matter how loud I yelled for Laine to run the other way, it didn’t matter. Because this was Laine and Leah’s story, not mine. Life’s lessons are learned in many different ways.
Congratulations to the courageous
for wading into those lives and writing Laine’s story so that it felt like my own.