I submitted the middle-grade of my heart to an editor who was at our local conference last fall and haven’t heard a peep. I just went to my sub timeline and marked it as a No Response = PASS submission.
Closure is good. Not always painless, but still, a good and necessary perspective.
I’m sorry that this door wasn’t opened for you, Tracy, but I believe with all my heart that there will be another entrance, better suited to you and your project.
LikeLike
That’s a lovely thought and I’d love for it to be true. Thank you, friend.
LikeLike
I so agree with Melodye! 🙂
LikeLike
Well, we all know Melodye is exceedingly wise, so….
Thank you for the good thoughts.
LikeLike
😦
LikeLike
Yep.
LikeLike
I’m sorry. Feel the pain. Breathe. Listen to Melodye. xo
LikeLike
Definitely feeling the pain, but also feeling a sense of release. Thank you for breathing with me.
LikeLike
Did you cold-query, or was this an editor you had pitched who asked for the ms.? If the latter, did you status-query at all?
*hugs*
LikeLike
I didn’t pitch this editor, just sent the ms to her because she was accepting them from conference attendees. However, I felt like it was a good fit and was so sure I’d hear back from her, which is why it’s hard to face the reality that she didn’t feel the love.
LikeLike
Well, I agree both with Melodye and with Jenn. If you met the editor and she/he asked for the manuscript, don’t assume a “no” because of a non-response. In similar situations, I received: a) a lovely, encouraging, personal decline with request for more manuscripts after *six months*, and b) a personal decline after *277 days* (yes, I counted). If she asked for the ms. you deserve an answer. Send a polite status query. You have nothing to lose.
LikeLike
Alas, I didn’t receive a request from the editor. I didn’t have a pitch session or critique with her, only felt my book was a good fit for her house.
LikeLike
Sending hugs, Tracy. This business is so hard. But much as I understand the relief that closure can bring, I should tell you that I’ve had acceptances come a full 9 months after submission. Whatever happens, I hope the MG of your heart finds the right home!
LikeLike
It was hard to record PASS in my log, but it was getting harder to hold out hope that felt increasingly delusional. HA. I get your point, though, that there are many, many instances of YES coming way after submission. That would be a pleasant surprise, for sure. I appreciate the hugs, Amy.
LikeLike